Fivecardguys.com is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Andrew Benintendi and his top 3 rookie cards

  • 2 min read

Andrew Benintendi of the Boston Red Sox was a top prospect and rookie of the year candidate going into the 2017 season.

And he still might be as Benintendi continues to produce consistently although catching up to the great Aaron Judge (who has significantly cooled down in the second half) might prove to be a difficult task.

Here’s the top 3 we like best (links to each card listed on eBay below).

2017 Topps Heritage autograph rookie


Here’s a classic bat resting on the shoulder pose with a great profile shot of the rookie outfielder.

Harkening back to the golden years of baseball card collecting, the Topps Heritage rookie card also has the RC symbol on it.

Plus this one is autographed (although non-autograph versions are significantly cheaper).

2017 Topps Heritage Andrew Benintendi Rookie Auto BGS 10 Pristine RC! (1) LEFT

$200.00  
End Date: Saturday Oct-24-2020 19:18:20 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $200.00
Buy It Now

2017 Topps Heritage Andrew Benintendi Real One Red Ink RC Auto /68 BGS 9.5 10

$350.00  
End Date: Sunday Oct-04-2020 03:12:52 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $350.00
Buy It Now

2017 Topps Heritage Andrew Benintendi Real One RC Rookie Auto BGS 9.5 10

$140.00  
End Date: Sunday Oct-11-2020 00:13:53 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $140.00
Buy It Now

2017 Topps Finest autographed rookie

For those who like a more modern look with a flashier design, the Topps Finest rookie card fits that bill.

It also has the RC symbol on it and having his last name enlarged gives it a sharp look.

Plus this card is also autographed on-card.

ANDREW BENINTENDI 2017 TOPPS FINEST RC RED WAVE REFRACTOR AUTO /25 BGS 9 AUTO 10

$154.00  
End Date: Wednesday Oct-28-2020 13:52:13 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $154.00
Buy It Now

2017 Topps Finest 1sts Andrew Benintendi Red Sox RC Red Wave Auto 17/25 BGS 9.5

$199.00  
End Date: Wednesday Oct-14-2020 16:50:11 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $199.00
Buy It Now

Andrew Benintendi 2017 Topps Finest Auto #d /25 RC Orange BGS 9.5 10 Red Sox

$214.99  
End Date: Friday Oct-23-2020 21:02:02 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $214.99
Buy It Now


2015 Bowman Chrome Draft autographed rookie

Most likely the most popular to collect is Benintendi’s 2015 Bowman Chrome Draft autographed rookie card.

While technically a prospect card, collectors treat the 1st Bowman card as a rookie card.

The on-card autograph is obviously a nice value add and there are plenty of colored refractors available too.

Andrew Benintendi 2015 Bowman Chrome Draft auto Rookie Card (RC) BGS 9.5/10

$199.99  
End Date: Friday Oct-09-2020 09:10:55 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $199.99
Buy It Now

2015 BOWMAN CHROME DRAFT ANDREW BENINTENDI ROOKIE RC AUTO BGS 9.5 / 10 AUTO

$109.99  
End Date: Sunday Oct-04-2020 21:06:12 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $109.99
Buy It Now

Andrew Benintendi 2015 Bowman Chrome Draft RC Rookie Auto BGS 9.5 Gem Mint #AB

$199.99  
End Date: Tuesday Oct-13-2020 17:03:22 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $199.99
Buy It Now

ANDREW BENINTENDI 2015 BOWMAN CHROME DRAFT AUTO ROOKIE RC RED SOX BGS 9.5 10

$299.99  
End Date: Sunday Oct-11-2020 20:28:47 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $299.99
Buy It Now

ANDREW BENINTENDI 2015 BOWMAN CHROME DRAFT AUTO ROOKIE RC RED SOX BGS 9 10

$249.99  
End Date: Sunday Oct-25-2020 15:40:05 EDT
Buy It Now for only: $249.99
Buy It Now

CK

For some of the best sports card auctions currently listed, check out our Daily Auctions page (link in menu) which is updated regularly!

Leave a Reply